German Reverse Seared NY Strip with Crushed Red Pepper Parmesan Sauce

Master the Flame with German Reverse Seared NY Strip on a Dual Fuel Grill

When steak night calls for something bold, flavorful, and unforgettable—this German-inspired reverse seared NY strip recipe delivers. Infused with hickory smoke, finished with a fiery sear, and topped with a creamy crushed red pepper Parmesan sauce, it’s everything you want in a steak and more. And the secret to nailing this recipe? It’s all about the grill.

Char-Griller Dual Fuel Combo grills are your go-to tool for steakhouse-level results at home. With both gas and charcoal cooking zones—and the ability to attach a Side Fire Box—this grill gives you the flexibility to go low and slow with real wood smoke, then finish with high-heat precision on the gas side. It’s versatility without compromise, and it makes reverse searing easier than ever.

Dual fuel grills, sometimes called combo grills or dual-function grills or multifuel grills, are a newer style of grill that combines the best of charcoal grilling along with the convenience of a gas grill in one.

Why Dual Fuel Grills Make the Cut

Dual fuel grills bring the best of both worlds to your backyard: the rich, smoky flavor of charcoal and wood, and the convenience and control of propane. Whether you’re searing steaks, smoking ribs, or doing both in the same cook, a dual fuel setup gives you unmatched adaptability—making it ideal for cooks who want variety without switching grills.

Dual fuel grills work by having one side of the grill function with charcoal and the other side function with gas or propane. This is perfect for being versatile - use charcoal when you have a little more time to grill and use propane or gas side for a faster grilling experience

Pro Tips for Steakhouse-Worthy Results

Want to take your cook from great to unforgettable? Keep these expert tips in mind to get the most out of your grill and your recipe:

  • Score the Fat Cap: Creating a diamond pattern in the fat cap helps render it evenly and absorb more seasoning.
  • Clean Smoke Matters: Always wait for wood chunks to ignite fully before closing the lid. Clean-burning smoke = better flavor.
  • Rest Before You Sear: Letting the loin rest before slicing and searing prevents juices from escaping.
  • Sauce as a Sear Base: Spreading the crushed red pepper Parmesan sauce before searing caramelizes the top and creates a bold crust.
  • Add Real Smoke with Hickory Wood Chunks: For this NY strip recipe, hickory wood chunks are the key to building deep, savory flavor. Hickory pairs especially well with beef, delivering a bold, slightly sweet smoke that enhances every bite.Ā 

Attaching the Side Fire Box for Smoking

For serious smokers, the Char-Griller Side Fire Box attachment is a must. It transforms any Char-Griller grill (even duel fuels) into a powerful offset smoker, letting you maintain steady indirect heat while infusing your meat with real hardwood smoke. Perfect for the reverse sear method, the Side Fire Box allows you to slow-cook the strip loin away from direct flame, building flavor low and slow before finishing with a gas-powered sear. With adjustable dampers and consistent airflow, it’s your ticket to controlled smoking and restaurant-worthy results—right in your backyard.

Ready to fire it up? Follow the steps below and experience the perfect balance of smoke, sear, and spice—all made better with the Char-Griller Combo Gas and Charcoal Grills and Side Fire Box attachment.Ā 

German Reverse Seared NY Strip with Crushed Red Pepper Parmesan Sauce

Serves:
4
Cook Time:
30 - 60 min

Ingredients

How many people are you serving?

e

  • NY Strip Loin

  • Crushed Red Pepper Parmesan Sauce

This German-style reverse seared NY strip loin combines the best of smoky, savory barbecue with creamy heat from a crushed red pepper Parmesan sauce. Grilled low and slow to build flavor, then finished with a quick high-heat sear, this method locks in juices while creating a mouthwatering crust. It’s an unforgettable cook that will elevate any backyard gathering.

ā€œSmoky, creamy, and packed with bold flavor—this reverse seared NY strip is the star of any steak night.ā€

The Char-Griller Dual Fuel Pro with the Side Fire Box attached is ideal for reverse searing NY strip because it offers precise heat control and true versatility. You can smoke low and slow with charcoal and hickory wood in the Side Fire Box, then crank up the gas side for a quick, high-heat sear. With plenty of cooking space and adjustable dampers, it's built for mastering both flavor and finish in one seamless cook.

Instructions

  1. 01

    Light and stabilize your grill to 300°F, setting it up for indirect cooking by banking the charcoal to one side. Add hickory wood chunks to the hottest area and wait for them to ignite fully for clean smoke.

  2. 02

    Using a sharp knife, score a diamond pattern into the fat cap and underside of the strip loin. Season the entire loin generously with salt and pepper, making sure to work the seasoning into the cuts.

  3. 03

    Place the seasoned strip loin fat cap side down on the indirect side of the grill. Close the lid and smoke for 30 minutes. Flip the strip loin and continue smoking until the internal temperature reaches 115°F to 125°F, depending on your desired doneness.

  4. 04

    Transfer the smoked strip loin to a cutting board and let it rest for 10–15 minutes. Meanwhile, increase your grill temperature to 550°F or higher for direct searing.

  5. 05

    Slice the strip loin into individual steaks. Spread a generous layer of Crushed Red Pepper Parmesan Sauce on the cut side of each steak and sprinkle with additional black pepper or brisket seasoning.

  6. 06

    Place each steak sauce side down on the hottest part of the grill. Sear for 45 seconds to 1 minute, developing a flavorful crust.

  7. 07

    Remove steaks, slice into ¼-inch thick strips, and top with more Crushed Red Pepper Parmesan Sauce. Serve hot and enjoy!